top of page
KRATIKO-(A.M.K.E.)-logo
Get Involved

Policy Directives

Directive (EU) 2015/412: GMO Opt-Out Mechanism

Amending Directive 2001/18/EC, this directive allows EU Member States to restrict or ban the cultivation of authorized Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) in all or part of their territory without challenging the European Food Safety Authority's (EFSA) scientific safety assessments.

​

  • Two-Phase Mechanism:

    • Phase 1 (During Authorization): A Member State requests the European Commission to adjust the geographical scope of the pending authorization application so that its territory is excluded. If the applicant (seed/biotech company) agrees within 30 days, the exclusion is integrated directly into the EU-wide authorization.

    • Phase 2 (Post-Authorization): If the applicant objects during Phase 1, or after a crop has already been authorized at the EU level, the state can adopt national transitional measures banning cultivation based on distinct legal grounds.

  • Permissible Non-Scientific Grounds: Opt-outs cannot be justified by environmental/health risks already addressed by EFSA. Permissible justifications include:

    • Environmental policy objectives distinct from EFSA assessments (e.g., maintaining local ecosystem resilience, preventing gene flow into wild flora).

    • Town and country planning / land-use zoning.

    • Socio-economic impacts (e.g., avoiding coexistence costs or contamination of organic farming supply chains).

    • Agricultural policy objectives (e.g., preserving distinct crop varieties or traditional farming practices).

    • Public policy (ordre public).

  • Application in Greece: Greece maintains an active nationwide ban on the cultivation of all commercial GMO crops (including MON 810 maize). The policy protects the country’s high proportion of smallholder farming, PDO/PGI-certified regional agricultural goods, and growing organic export market from genetic cross-contamination.

Article 191 TFEU: The Precautionary Principle

Enshrined in Article 191(2) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), the Precautionary Principle provides a legal basis for preventive policy when scientific evidence is inconclusive, uncertain, or preliminary, but reasonable grounds suggest potential irreversible harm to human health or the environment.

  • Key Legal Elements & Operational Criteria (Commission Communication COM(2000) 1):

    • Scientific Evaluation: Action must begin with an independent scientific assessment determining the degree of uncertainty.

    • Proportionality: Preventive measures must not exceed what is necessary to achieve the desired level of protection.

    • Non-Discrimination: Comparable situations must not be treated differently without objective justification.

    • Cost-Benefit Assessment: Authorities must weigh potential short- and long-term costs of action versus inaction.

    • Reviewability: Measures must be provisional and subject to reassessment as new scientific data emerges.

  • Burden of Proof: Under specific regulatory regimes applying this principle (e.g., REACH chemical authorizations, novel food clearances), the evidentiary burden shifts from public authorities (proving harm) to commercial applicants (demonstrating safety before market access).

Directive 2009/128/EC & Greek Law 4036/2012: Sustainable Use of Pesticides

Directive 2009/128/EC establishes community standards to reduce the risks and impacts of Plant Protection Products (PPPs) on human health and the environment, mandating the adoption of Integrated Pest Management (IPM) and dedicated National Action Plans (NAPs).

  • Mandatory Framework Components:

    • Integrated Pest Management (IPM): Mandatory prioritization of non-chemical, biological, and physical plant protection alternatives before chemical interventions are permitted.

    • Equipment & Training: Mandatory regular inspection/calibration of pesticide application equipment and certified professional operator training.

    • Aerial Spraying Prohibition: General ban on aerial pesticide spraying across the EU, permitted only under narrow derogations.

  • Protected Zones & Sensitive Areas (Article 12):

    • Requires explicit reduction or prohibition of pesticide application in ecological and public zones.

    • Natura 2000 & Habitat Sites: Protection of Special Protection Areas (SPAs) and Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) from drift and chemical runoff.

    • Aquatic Environments: Buffer zones along surface waters, wetlands, and designated drinking water abstraction catchments.

    • Public Access Areas: Near schools, playgrounds, healthcare facilities, and urban green spaces.

  • Greek Implementation (Law 4036/2012):

    • Transposed the directive and introduced a centralized electronic registry for the commercial distribution of PPPs.

    • Established the digital "Electronic Prescription for Plant Protection Products," requiring authorized agronomists to sign off on specific chemical pesticide purchases and usages.

    • Enforces buffer zones and restricted spraying mandates around water bodies and agricultural zones adjacent to Greek Natura 2000 networks.

bottom of page